北京第二外国语学院学报 ›› 2015, Vol. 37 ›› Issue (6): 48-.

• 外国文学研究 • 上一篇    下一篇

柏拉图:诗哲之争还是诗哲对话?

牛红英   

  1. 天津工业大学外国语学院 天津 300387
  • 收稿日期:2015-02-26 出版日期:2015-06-30 发布日期:2018-03-20
  • 作者简介:牛红英(1971— ),女,河北邯郸人,天津工业大学外国语学院副教授,文学博士,硕导,主要研究 西方文学。

Plato: Quarrel or Dialogue between Poetry and Philosophy?

Niu Hongying   

  1. Tianjin Polytechnic University, Tianjin 300387, China
  • Received:2015-02-26 Online:2015-06-30 Published:2018-03-20

摘要: 本文旨在对柏拉图笔下的诗哲之争这个古老的西方命题进行新的解读。尽管学界对诗哲之争一直视为理所当然,但是本文从跨学科的视角指出,无论是从柏拉图自身的气质还是其对话来仔细判断,诗与哲学的争执都只是一种假象。正如哲学家柏拉图同时也是诗人柏拉图,诗与哲学不过是表述同一个世界的两种话语。它们之间真正的关系与其说是争执性的,不如说是对话性的。重估诗哲关系需要当代柏拉图研究者打破专业藩篱,相互借力。本文的研究将在一定程度上更新学界对诗哲关系以及柏拉图的认知。

关键词: 柏拉图; 诗; 哲学; 争执; 对话

Abstract: This paper studies anew the old topic of the quarrel between poetry and philosophy put forward by Plato. While the quarrel has been taken for granted, this study argues from a cross-disciplinary perspective that the so-called quarrel is a deception if we judge Plato’s temperament and dialogues as a whole. As Plato is both a poet and philosopher, poetry and philosophy are two discourses he adopts in approaching the same world. The actual relationship between poetry and philosophy is more dialogic than antagonistic. It is necessary for Platonic scholars of different fields to step across their disciplinary boundaries and learn from each other. This paper would to some extent update the scholarship about this topic and Plato.

Keywords: Plato; poetry; philosophy; quarrel; dialogue